Imagine you are making a YouTube video. You have your script ready and now all you want is the conversion of that written text into an appealing voice. But you are confused between choosing Human voice or AI voice. You are wondering: which one is best? These days, both clients and designers find it convenient to rely on AI. But is it worth relying upon this new trend?
Today, in this blog, we will talk in detail about the good and bad that come with adopting both.
Let’s start the discussion!
Human Vs AI Voice-Over Debate
The debate surrounding human or AI voice-over was not there in the distant past. Human beings used to have complete dominance over voice-over arts. All the voices, the ones you hear in cartoons or hilarious voices you hear when listening to stories, were all given by real vocal folds.
But then came the artificial intelligence game-changer. They were highly intelligent voice-over tools created by humans to the detriment of humans. This new development with machines imitating the warmth and uniqueness of human voice revolutionized the landscape of voice-over generation.
Today, many people are turning towards AI, calling it a great time saver. It has, indeed, become a cost-cutting tool for making a voice-over. However, there do exist some sections of people who shudder at its sounding too robotic.
Is Human Voice-Overs Better Than AI Voice-Overs?
Now, let’s talk about the pros and cons of human voices that are not soulless:
Advantages of Using Human Voice-Overs
They Best Reflect Emotions and Authenticity
When a real person is speaking a line, he is not just reading by changing his tone, style, and pitch. He is feeling the written scenario to produce the best outcome out of it. He is adding feelings of sadness, excitement, and humor into his voice-over, as needed.
For example, you can assess whether a person is frightened or happy by just observing the tone of his voice. Therefore, it would not be wrong to say that tone matters more than words to accurately interpret what the person is actually trying to say. Machines? They are not quite good at it yet.
Humans Are Much Better For Customized Voice-Overs
Do you want to add a dramatic pause in your story? Or do you prefer a sarcastic delivery of scripted lines? Whatever the case, humans are much better at delivering your customized requirements. For them, it is much easier to flow with the mood and energy of something. Why so? They have a heart and, not to forget, a consciousness, which, till now, robots don’t have. What’s more? Unlike robots, humans have the power of imagination, which gives them the ability to understand the underlying emotions behind text better.
Humans Are Better At Building Connections
As humans, we are evolutionarily primed to react to other people. Faciality makes people buy in and pay attention. Our souls get engrossed in the text, building relatability with what’s written and ultimately believing and most definitely producing convincing voice-overs. AI is not able to do that. They are able to produce sounds, but not narrative. That is still a specialty of humans.
Disadvantages of Using Human Voice-Overs
Human Voice-Overs Tolls on Both Time and Cost
Honestly speaking, if you take your project to a professional voice artist, it is not going to be a cheap exercise. It may drain your time and budget. After all, quality and uniqueness are expensive.
Right Human Voice is Difficult to Find
It does not come easy to locate the right voice. It will require auditions, criticism, and changes. Indeed, the whole procedure is quite extensive.
Are AI Voice-Overs Better Than Humans’ Voice-Overs?
AI is a new trend in the world. The whole world is going crazy because of it. Underpinned by mind-blowing technology, this new invention is replacing humans like never before. No more is this technology limited to just reading out the simplified text of an e-book or an article. It is now entering into the creative realm that was till now exclusive to humans.
Let’s discuss some pros and cons of this unprecedented change:
Advantages of Using AI Voice-Overs
AI Work Is Speedy and Convenient
Are you worried because your deadline is literally over your head, and you have not done anything? No tension at all. Now, AI voice generators turn your script into words in minutes. You don’t have to fret yourself on callbacks and doing re-recordings of over an hour.
AI Is Cost-Effective
Human voice talents require payable fees and royalty charges where applicable. However, AI voice-over services come with just a subscription fee. You can also find many free AI voice-over tools in the market tool. It would not be an overstatement to say that AI is a god-sent tool for many young startups, and creators having little capital to invest.
AI Is Consistent
Unlike humans, you don’t have to satisfy labor standards. They can work for you 24/7 without feeling exhausted. Looks like AI is always more serious about its job. And when I say serious, I mean no off days and no coffee breaks! Just work, work, and work.
Disadvantages of Using AI Voice-Overs
AI is a double-edged sword. Remember, with a rose comes the thorns too. Here are some obvious disadvantages of using AI voice-overs:
AI Lack Depth
Ok, I won’t lie but yeah, there exist numerous examples of AI’s ability to simulate emotions. However, it fails to have them fully. One can easily sense what is generated by AI and what is humanistic. Indeed, AI voice-overs lack depth, and it is somewhat mechanistic, which causes viewers to remain detached and unable to relate to the content.
AI Has Associated Ethical Concerns
Some platforms are now using AI detectors to discern AI-generated content. The point is AI is emerging as a popular search engine among users. And traditional search engine platforms like Google and YouTube are considering it as an existential threat. The increasing use of AI for search purposes is decreasing the use and relevancy of these platforms for users. Therefore, these platforms are looking for ways to stop the dominance of AI-generated content.
YouTube AI voice detectors consider content created by AI less authentic and excessive use of such voice-over can harm your channel’s credibility in the long-term.
AI Has Limited Flexibility
If you need spontaneous adjustments in just one part of your voice, AI does not work for that. It cannot invent or understand the art of perfecting the flow. It also does not cater to the unique requirements of the clients. It’s humans who can perform this task better.
Final Thoughts
UnityFilms recognizes the importance of both in generating voice-overs. Throughout history, change has only been a constant phenomenon. It is this change that started the Industrial Age, and now it is this change that is spurring the AI age.
Thrive in this AI age by leveraging the best AI voice-over services from UnityFilms. And if you want to customize your voice-over by giving a human touch, we have that for you, too.
Just contact us to get the best quote!
